| 1887 | Mrs. Laura Miller | Lancaster, PA |
| 1887-1888 | Mrs. W.D.A. O’Brien | Sidney, OH |
| 1889-1890 | Mrs. Ella L. Jones | Swissvale, PA |
| 1891 | Mrs. J.S Mason | Medina, OH |
| 1891-1893 | Mrs. Belle Gray Rice | Washington, IA |
| 1894-1896 | Mrs. Margaret Howey Coe | Springfield, IL |
| 1897 | Mrs. Kate G. Raynor | Toledo, OH |
| 1898 | Mrs. Elizabeth H.R. Davis | Takoma Park, DC |
| 1899 | Mrs. May L. Warren | Greenwood, MA |
| 1900-1902 | Mrs. Lida Tomer-Miller | Rochester, NY |
| 1903-1904 | Mrs. Addie M. Wallace | Indianapolis, IN |
| 1905-1906 | Mrs. Kate E. Hardcastle Carr | Camden, NJ |
| 1907 | Mrs. Julia A. Moynihan | Rochester, NY |
| 1908 | Miss Mamie E. Herbst | South Canton, OH |
| 1909-1910 | Mrs. Molly Donaldson Hammer | Reading, PA |
| 1911 | Mrs. H. Pauline Creighton | Campaign, IL |
| 1912 | Mrs. Flora A. S. Whitney | Marlboro, MA |
| 1913 | Mrs. Frances Fox Moynihan | Rochester, MY |
| 1914 | Mrs. Edna Bergwitz | Columbus, OH |
| 1915 | Mrs. Bessie B. Bowser | Indianapolis, IN |
| 1916 | Mrs. Libbie Meis Overbrook | Philadelphia, PA |
| 1917 | Mrs. Mae E. Clothier | Rockford, IL |
| 1918 | Mrs. Mayme E. Dwyer | Long Island City, NY |
| 1919 | Mrs. Margaret Carney | Melrose, MA |
| 1920 | Miss Mary L. Tredo | Patterson, NJ |
| 1921 | Mrs. Blanche L. Beverstock | Keene, NH |
| 1922 | Mrs. Margaret Patterson Stephens | Columbus, OH |
| 1923 | Mrs. Minnie E. Groth | Baraboo, WI |
| 1924 | Mrs. Emma Stuart Finch | Bridgeport, IN |
| 1925 | Mrs. Ida Rokes Klein | Syracuse, NY |
| 1926 | Mrs. Mamie M. Deems | Los Angeles, CA |
| 1927 | Mrs. Anna F. Keene | Philadelphia, PA |
| 1928 | Mrs. Margaret L. Waters | Woburn, MA |
| 1929 | Mrs. Elizabeth C. Hansen | Weehawken, NJ |
| 1930 | Mrs. Ida B. Lange | Rutherford, NJ |
| 1931 | Mrs. Celeste D. Gentieu | Wilmington, DE |
| 1932 | Mrs. Wilma L. Combs | Des Moines, IA |
| 1933 | Mrs. Jean B. Thompson | St. Petersburg, FL |
| 1934 | Mrs. Margaret F. Anderson | Tacoma, WA |
| 1935 | Mrs. Gertrude M. Sautter | Clearwater, FL |
| 1936 | Mrs. Stella B. Owen | Upper Montclair, NJ |
| 1937 | Mrs. Ida B. Lewis | Milwaukee, WI |
| 1938 | Mrs. Margaret C. Brady | Albany, NY |
| 1939 | Mrs. Anne E. Lockyer | Steubenville, OH |
| 1940 | Mrs. Eva B. Blackman | Chicago, IL |
| 1941 | Mrs. Clara M. Gallagher | Philadelphia, PA |
| 1942 | Mrs. Margaret D. Schroeder | Ft. Lauderdale, FL |
| 1943 | Mrs. Mary E. Stapleton | Albany, NY |
| 1944 | Mrs. Maude B. Warren | Brockton, MA |
| 1945 | Mrs. Edith B. Nile | Alliance, OH |
| 1946 | Mrs. Gladys B. Sallman | Valparaiso, IN |
| 1947 | Mrs. Edna S. Lambert | Lithonia, GA |
| 1948 | Mrs. Katherine L. Joyce | Pittsburgh, PA |
| 1949 | Mrs. Lena G. Barrett | Santa Ana, CA |
| 1950 | Mrs. Ethelyn C. Tucker | San Diego, CA |
| 1951 | Mrs. Lela B. Shugart | Warren, IN |
| 1952 | Mrs. Phyllis Dean | Westboro, MA |
| 1953 | Mrs. Lila A. Macey | Schenectady, NY |
| 1954 | Mrs. Mildred R. Webster | Springvale, ME |
| 1955 | Mrs. Ellinore K. Johnson | Madison, WI |
| 1956 | Mrs. Lenore D. Glass | San Jose, CA |
| 1957 | Mrs. Margaret McKinney | Somers Point, NJ |
| 1958 | Miss Anne O. Clayton | Trenton, NJ |
| 1959 | Mrs. Ursula W. Stepardson | Springfield, MA |
| 1960 | Mrs. Beatrice S. Riggs | Las Vegas, NV |
| 1961 | Miss Edith M. Paulding | Parkway, NJ |
| 1962 | Mrs. Dorothy Hilyard | Wilmigton, DE |
| 1963 | Mrs. Anna I. Stoudt | Reading, PA |
| 1964 | Mrs. Anita Selby | Mansfield, OH |
| 1965 | Mrs. Emma Wheeler | Milford, NH |
| 1966 | Mrs. Edith Snyder | West Palm Beach, FL |
| 1967 | Miss Flora D. Bates | Shrewsbury, MA |
| 1968 | Mrs. Hazel L. Moushey | St. Louis, MO |
| 1969 | Mrs. Irene Murphy Stoudt | West Lawn, PA |
| 1970 | Mrs. Florence M. Jansson | Houston, TX |
| 1971 | Mrs. Eileen Coombs | Warwick, RI |
| 1972 | Mrs. Agnes D. Davis | Wilmington, DE |
| 1973 | Miss Viola L. Bremme | Philadelphia, PA |
| 1974-1975 | Mrs. Jessie G. Wells | Cambridge, MA |
| 1976 | Mrs. Caroline E. Riddell | Philadelphia, PA |
| 1977 | Mrs. Minnie E. Maderios | New Bedford, MA |
| 1978 | Mrs. Marion Combs | Upland, CA |
| 1979 | Mrs. Florence H. Forbey | Phoenix, AZ |
| 1980 | Mrs. Nellie H. Hawley | Fort Dodge, IA |
| 1981 | Mrs. Lelia M. Turner | Randolph, MA |
| 1982 | Miss Ann E. Willeke | Rockville, CT |
| 1983 | Mrs. Dorris W. Schlenker | Rockville, MD |
| 1984 | Mrs. Mary Jane Simpson | West Lawn, PA |
| 1985 | Mrs. Jennie Russell | Malden, MA |
| 1986 | Mrs. Isabelle Roberts | Owego, NY |
| 1987 | Mrs Esther Peiper | Columbus, OH |
| 1988 | Mrs. Betty Woerner Downs | Monte Rio, CA |
| 1989 | Mrs. Catherine Zapatka | Newington, CT |
| 1990 | Mrs. Beatrice Greenwalt | Ovid, NY |
| 1991 | Mrs. Ora Moitoso | Providence, RI |
| 1992 | Mrs. Ethel Carver | New Castle, DE |
| 1993 | Mrs. Frances Murray | Brunswick, ME |
| 1994 | Mrs. Florence Spring | Hamburg, PA |
| 1995-1996 | Mrs. Margaret Atkinson | Philadelphia, PA |
| 1997 | Mrs. Betty J. Baker | Interlaken, NY |
| 1998 | Mrs. Jacquelyn Johnston | Amherst, NH |
| 1999 | Mrs. Betty J. Baker | Interlaken, NY |
| 2000 | Mrs. Mary Jo Long | Duryea, PA |
| 2001 | Mrs. Mary Scofield | Cromwell, CT |
| 2002 | Mrs. Faye Carlisle | Cogan Station, PA |
| 2003 | Mrs. Cynthia Brown | Salem, NH |
| 2004 | Mrs. Danielle Michaels | Franklin, WI |
| 2005 | Mrs. Michelle Langley | Interlaken, NY |
| 2006 | Mrs. Cynthia Fox | Williamsport, PA |
| 2007 | Mrs. Barbara Mayberry | Springfield, MA |
| 2008 | Mrs. Judith Trepanier | Cromwell, CT |
| 2009 | Mrs. Janice Harding | Baltimore, MD |
| 2010 | Mrs. Nancy Greenwalt Hilton | Alliance, OH |
| 2011 | Mrs. Virginia Twist | Ovid, NY |
| 2012 | sanctioned & removed | |
| 2013 | Mrs. Jane Graham | Alliance, OH |
| 2014 | Mrs. Diane Mellor | Nashua, NH |
| 2015 | Mrs. Rachelle Campbell | Gilroy, CA |
| 2016 | Mrs. Linda Kronberg | Tecumseh, MI |
| 2017 | Mrs. Denise Oman | WoneWoc, WI |
| 2018 | Ms. Ramona Greenwalt | Alliance, OH |
| 2019 | Mrs. Denise Oman | WoneWoc, WI |
| 2019-2021 | Mrs. Wanda Langdon | Cincinnati, OH |
| 2021-2023 | Mrs. Allison Pollitt | St. Louis, MO |
| 2023-2024 | Mrs. Sue Freshley | Willoughby, OH |
| 2024-2025 | Mrs. Rosemary Martin | Frederick, MD |